Blog Entry

Looking at the AL's worst defenders

Posted on: September 21, 2011 10:12 pm
Edited on: November 1, 2011 11:22 pm

By Evan Brunell

You've seen who Eye on Baseball tabs as the AL Gold Glove award winners, and who should take home the hardware in the NL. But let's flip the switch and take a look at who is deserving of tin gloves. That is, who were the worst defenders at their respective positions in the American League this season? Let's take a look.

Catcher: J.P. Arencibia, Blue Jays: -- The Jays would love it if Arencibia become a viable starter behind the plate. Unfortunately, that doesn't look as if it will work out. In his first full season as a catcher amassing 116 games, Arencibia registers as one of the worst catchers by advanced defensive metrics and more basic ones, too. Defensive Runs Scored (DRS), errors, caught stealing percentage, passed balls... all are leaderboards that Arencibia appears on, and not at the top.

First base: Miguel Cabrera, Tigers
-- Ah, first base ... where inept fielders make their home. That includes Miguel Cabrera, who is a really, really good hitter but just can't add value fielding. He doesn't have much range and is a statue in the field, leading all AL first basemen in errors with 12 (second in the majors behind Prince Fielder). There isn't anything in the field he does particularly well, so he lands here with a tin glove.

Second base: Jemile Weeks, Athletics
-- Weeks takes after his older brother, Rickie, in that he's just not a very good defender. Despite playing in just 88 games, Weeks has committed 12 errors, most among all second basemen. Ian Kinsler has committed one less error in 50 more games. Infielders -- middle infielders, especially -- can rack up errors if they have great range, committing miscues on balls that the average infielder wouldn't have gotten to. But even Weeks can't claim this, as his range factor is among the worst among second basemen.

Third base: Mark Reynolds, Orioles
-- This one is really easy, and is a player that everyone can agree on. Both advanced metrics and traditional defensive stats all agree that Reynolds is awful with -30 DRS, 26 errors and no range to speak of as well. There's a reason the Orioles have been giving Reynolds looks at first base, and it's because he's that bad at the hot corner.

Shortstop: Derek Jeter, Yankees
-- Yeah, Jeter has five Gold Gloves to his name, but that just shows you what's wrong with the voting process. The fact is that Jeter has been a bad shortstop, and been one for quite some time. He has zero range to speak of with poor reaction time and throwing accuracy or strength. His instincts and ability to make plays on balls he can get to can only take him so far.

Left field: Delmon Young, Tigers
-- You know how in the little leagues, the worst fielder was usually put out to pasture in left field, where he'd befriend weeds while the game played out around him? Yeah, well, that player turned out to hit pretty well, which is why Young is in the majors. Because he's certainly not in the bigs for his defense, which is among the worst in the league by any player at any position.

Center field: Alex Rios, White Sox
-- How much must GM Kenny Williams be regretting claiming Alex Rios off waivers? Not only has the center fielder not hit, he can't even fulfill playing his position. What does Rios in, and it's not like he does well at any aspect of defense this year, is his lack of instincts and range. He may have a solid .991 fielding percentage, but how much does that matter when you can't run balls down in the gaps?

Right field: Nick Markakis, Orioles
-- In right field, a player's arm is one of the more important characteristics as right-fielders need to be able to gun players out both at home and at third base. Markakis' arm is not one of his better attributes, but he's also lacking in speed which is odd given his 12 stolen bases are his most since 2007, but stealing bases and covering ground in the outfield are two very different things.

Pitcher: A.J. Burnett, Yankees
-- As a pitcher, range doesn't really matter. If a ball goes somewhere easily out of the reach of the pitcher, other fielders will handle the play. So it can be tricky to gauge just how good of a fielder a pitcher is. Looking at errors is one way to judge how surehanded a pitcher is, and Burnett's five errors tie him with two others. He doesn't have good range either, with his lack of mobility leading to just eight putouts and 21 assists, which rank at the bottom of the pack.

For more baseball news, rumors and analysis, follow @EyeonBaseball on Twitter or subscribe to the RSS feed.

Since: Dec 2, 2011
Posted on: December 20, 2011 12:15 pm
This comment has been removed.

Post Deleted by Administrator

Since: Dec 2, 2011
Posted on: December 18, 2011 4:52 am
This comment has been removed.

Post Deleted by Administrator

Since: Dec 2, 2011
Posted on: December 7, 2011 7:11 pm

Looking at the AL's worst defenders

Everything that themed are you currently engaging with exclusively on your own area ? My wife and i in reality much like the creation. Thanks for your send.

Since: Oct 19, 2011
Posted on: November 2, 2011 6:05 pm

Looking at the AL's worst defenders

Hey about manning up and acknowledging that your smear of Nick Markakis was wrong?  I mean he only won the Gold Glove as the best rightfielder in the A.L.

Since: Oct 19, 2011
Posted on: October 19, 2011 8:13 pm

Looking at the AL's worst defenders

Check out this video on YouTube:
_player You know nothing about baseball putting Markakis on this list. Just watch the limited 2011 montage and reconsider your ridiculous statement.

Since: Sep 17, 2007
Posted on: October 19, 2011 12:17 am

Looking at the AL's worst defenders

Hey Evan, how much do you get paid to come up with gems like "Markakis' arm is not one of his better attributes"? Nick Markakis played as both an outfielder and a pitcher in College and he has one of the better outfield arms in baseball.

Since: Aug 22, 2006
Posted on: October 18, 2011 7:20 pm

Looking at the AL's worst defenders

Wait...Markakis' arm isn't one of his better attributes? Have you ever seen him play even once? His arm is his BEST attribute. Hell...there's even a YouTube video dedicated to it. 

Since: Nov 30, 2007
Posted on: September 27, 2011 10:08 pm

Looking at the AL's worst defenders

Pretty surprised Tsuyoshi Nishioka isn't on this list, I thought he was a lock

Since: Aug 4, 2010
Posted on: September 27, 2011 9:21 pm

Looking at the AL's worst defenders

I cannot believe you have Nick Markakis on this list.  If you watch ANY baseball at all, you would know this guy is one of baseball's top fielding right fielders.  He covers a ton of ground, makes weekly highlught reel catches - how about the diving catch tonight vs Boston with the bases loaded to save 3 runs?  His arm?  He has averaged 12 assists per year for his career.  How about 325 consecutive errorless games currently?  Who is a better right fielder in the AL?  Drew?  Swisher? Cuddyer?  Quentin?  Ordonez? Ichiro?  You really need to watch some baseball before attempting a list like this.  And Jeter on this list?  You are actually believing that Peralta is a better defensive SS?  Escobar?  Scutaro?   

Since: Jan 21, 2007
Posted on: September 21, 2011 10:34 pm

Looking at the AL's worst defenders

How about adding the pitching staff of the Athletics as a whole? As for Jemile Weeks, he's a rookie, so I'm giving him a pass unlike his double play counterpart, Cliff Pennington.

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or